Sunday, November 15, 2009

Preproposal: My Ideas so Far

Background Information
Since teachers first incorporated computers into the writing classroom, academics have questioned the rhetoric of technology use. As computer technologies developed, distant education courses formed, which gave more non-traditional students access to higher levels of education. With the growing number of distant education courses came debate: some educators praised the idea of making education more accessible, while others claimed online courses would weaken the integrity of the university.

More people have come to accept the idea of distant education courses, but many are still leery of the idea because they are unsure of whether or not students receive the same quality of education in online courses. Although scholars and teachers today widely accept the idea that strategies used in traditional classrooms will not transfer directly to online classrooms, more research is needed to determine the quality of education students receive in online courses. In order for online courses to be fully accepted, scholars, teachers, and universities need reassurance that the “academic rigor” is not weakened in these digital spaces.

Research Questions
One way to begin determining whether online courses meet educators’ expectations as places of academically challenging students is to investigate how assessment happens in these courses. My research questions follow:
How do teachers provide feedback to students in online courses?
What kinds of feedback do teachers provide in online courses?
How does this feedback (quality or quantity) compare to face-to-face courses?
Do the technologies used influence how teachers respond?
How do students perceive the quality of response they receive in online courses compared to traditional courses?
Are students more or less likely to use response received in online courses for revision?

Research Design
I will need to use mixed methods to fully explore, research, and answer my main research question. I could possibly begin with a focus group to determine how teachers in face-to-face and online courses think and talk about assessment/feedback/response. A focus group might help me narrow my main research question(s). I would then conduct two case studies: one of a traditional classroom and one of an online course. In these case studies, I would observe the ways teachers responded to students’ writing, interview the teachers, and possibly interview the students about their satisfaction with feedback on their writing. I would definitely use textual/content analysis to determine the kinds of feedback teachers give to students by coding the types of responses to students’ work.

Literature Review
I plan to use literature that discusses assessment, pedagogy in online courses, and empirical studies that have compared traditional courses to online courses. These sources will come from Computers and Composition, Assessing Writing, and books about online pedagogy. I want to use sources from when the conversation about online learning began and more recent sources. The newer sources might have more specific information about current debates or how new technologies are being used in writing classrooms.

Any comments, questions, or suggestions? Let me know!

Wednesday, November 11, 2009

What Drives my Methods

For the research I will write about in the research proposal, I feel that the research question I began with has driven the methodology I would most likely use (because my ideology helped me to form my research question). Hopefully that makes sense. I have a specific question, and then I had to decide which method would be best to find answers to that question, whatever those questions might be.

To answer the question, "What am I passionately committed to in this project," I have to say this: I want to find an answer to my research question that will help inform our field of study in some way. I want people to be able to learn something from my research, and I want to be able to add to the debate about the value of online learning. If this turns into a dissertation, I do of course want to benefit from my own research; I hope that my research would make me a better teacher, which then means students might benefit from my research. I used to think dissertations as sitting on shelves in lonely places in libraries. I don't want my research to be lonely.