Saturday, September 19, 2009

Case Study Questions

My definition of case study has certainly started to expand since beginning class this semester. Researchers can use case studies to work with, observe, or interview groups of people, but they can also be used as a way to analyze a text (as the researcher did on Confucius's theory about "language, virtue, and persuasion"). Case studies distinguish themselves from other methods of research by being flexible--a researcher can begin to learn about an interest, use some way of learning that seems appropriate, and then use the results of the case study for further research. Case studies might help researchers figure out which kinds of methods will be best to further answer any questions the researcher has.

Because case studies usually look at a small sample of something or a small group of people, the results cannot be applied to a larger group of people--the results are not generalizable. The evidence a research finds for one case study might be true for that one group of people, but another case study might find completely different results, even if the case study is conducted in the same way. Case studies can't attempt to come to any general conclusion; it can only suggest what the answer might be or present new questions to start answering.

From what I know about the term "heuristic," I see case studies as heuristic studies that attempt to come to some answer--the one the researcher can best form based on his/her experiences and results from the case study. If a researcher suggests some kind of solution after doing a case study, that solution is what people speak of as "an educated guess" because the researcher is forming that solution on a small about of data. It can't be generalizable for the research.

2 comments:

  1. I love that your definition includes the idea of flexibility. I agree this is a real selling point of case studies. They are often where we start when we aren't exactly sure what we're looking for or what we'll find.
    As for heuristics, think of it as something that inspires you to learn more. In this case, case studies often inspire us to focus more deeply and to really dig into an area of interest once we use the case study to get past the surface of the issue.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like how you define heuristics as inspiring the researcher to learn more. I think that's a great way of thinking about it. I like this because I do realized that case studies lead to many more questions and many more ways a researcher could further explore an original question or interest. Just thinking about my own research interests, I can see how a case study might lead me to learn more about the ways teachers provide feedback to students, the ways students see certain kinds of feedback as more useful than others, etc. A case study could lead to a many other individual, yet related, studies.

    ReplyDelete