Tuesday, September 15, 2009

Research Paradigm

I can see value in all of the research paradigms we've discussed so far: postpositivist, social constructivist, advocacy/participatory, and pragmatic. As I read through definitions and descriptions Creswell provides for the research paradigms, I made annotations like "ok, yeah" and "I agree with this." However, I finally wrote, "Nope, this is the one" after reading the section on the pragmatic worldview. Let me explain.

At first, I liked how the advocacy and participartory worldview claimed to set out with an agenda and then create change, to help a group of people. I thought, "Yes, I want to help people. I want my research to mean something. Who doesn't?" But our class discussion made me re-think this newly forming identity I wanted to adopt. After more reflection, I saw problems with setting out with a specific agenda and defining a group's problem for them. How am I know label their problem without speaking with them first and getting to know them. I think I have the biggest issue with creating a solution for a problem that I define and then force people to adopt because my research shows them this is the way out of their problem. Rather, I want to use my research to help people--but allow them to decide how to use my research to help themselves (if they even believe they need help). So, let's see if this makes sense.

I believe that adopting a pragmatic worldview will allow me to offer my research to those people who want to do something with it. And I know that it will certainly, at least, help me fix problems in my own world, my own teaching. I think that pragmatists ask questions and attempt to understand problems but do not claim that any solution is the solution. Creswell says it nicely when he explains that "Truth is what works at the time" (11). Mixed methods will help us to understand an issue or problem from several different angles, and I liked the idea mentioned in class of triangulation (using several methods to "cover" the faults of each method).

Because the pragmatic worldview welcomes mixed methods and "freedom of choice" (Creswell 11), people who use this worldview probably have the most explaining to do. In other words, they probably spend more time justifying and defending their choices to others who do see the benefits of using mixed methods. But, maybe more people are beginning to adopt this worldview (as I noticed everyone in our group identified the most with the pragmatic worldview). I look forward to learning more about these worldviews and trying them out to see what will help me use my research to become a better scholar and teacher.

3 comments:

  1. haha Triangulation....I envision a Captain Planet moment where researchers hold up their rings and yell "Triangulation" and magic happens.

    I think mixed methods research can help address the issue of naming problems for people you spoke of in your second paragraph. Focus groups, for example, are a great way to talk to people within a community to hear what they think their issues are. Then, from that information, you can gain a sense of direction with the rest of your research.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I also want my research to be relevant. But I think that that actually takes quite a bit of work--admirable work, but work nonetheless. I think I've said this in class (and I can't remember where I got it...): you and your participants, because you share equally in the generation of knowledge, should share equally in the result of that knowledge. I think comp. or pedagogical research offers a few short cuts, but I still struggle with thinking about how my work affects my world.

    I also have some issues thinking (as you do) that I would want a community to define research parameters for me. For example, many of my students don't know what they need, and ask for grammatical help. Also, I don't want to appear, or to think of myself, as holding some magical talisman to fix the worlds' ills. In my M.A. I remember one of my professors saying that you cannot change the world with an English degree. I disagree. I hope. At the very least, I think a pragmatic paradigm is a step in the right direction.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Rachel, you are bringing up great questions. I am actually a little scared when folks don't really question their researcher (and I guess by extension world view) as far as knowledge construction, meaning-making, and agenda setting. In lots of ways I think of my own work as participatory, but I agree that can be problematic. It's hard for me not to impose my values and goals (even though I am often convinced they are pedagogically and theoretically sounds) on others. Maybe then the pragmatic approach is best - maybe the "truth" is that sometimes I need to take on action research methods and other times I need to really just observe. Are the two mutually exclusive?

    ReplyDelete