As mentioned before, I'm interested in teacher response to students' written work in online and face-to-face classrooms. Some possible research question include the following:
How do teachers respond to students' written work in traditional classrooms and online courses?
In what ways to teachers respond? What tools are used in both kinds of classrooms? Do these tools make responding easier? Do these tools change/influence the kinds of feedback teachers give? Do teachers in online courses respond differently/provide different kinds of feedback to students in online courses compared to face-to-face courses? If so, why? Are students receiving equally effective feedback in both kinds of classrooms?
In order to answer these questions (or some of them), I feel the best methodology would be a case study. Because I don't have one specific question to focus my research, a case study might help me to narrow down my focus or show me which directions the research could go. A case study would allow me to observe classrooms, code feedback on students' papers, and interview both teachers and students if necessary. I don't think a survey or just coding would be enough. I feel that I would need to have contact with participants in order to observe or discuss the reasoning behind the ways teachers decided to provide feedback. There would be a lot of information I couldn't simply interpret on my own or that I wouldn't feel comfortable trying to interpret without any kind of explanation from the participants.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I like your topic a lot. I am wondering if it will shake down to be sort of a face-to-face versus online study or just a study of general teacher response habits. I think your literature review will let you see the best way to shape some of your questions and to find what has been done in this area and where there are gaps (and there are tons) in the research. I also hope you consider adding in a focus group component like you mentioned in an earlier post. I think that might be a wonderful way to get the ball rolling on this topic and to lead you to the sorts of differences and variables you may wish to look at.
ReplyDeleteFinally, I wonder if this project will eventually find focus either from a teacher or a student perspective. In some ways these are very different ideas: How do teachers feel about responding to and assessing papers in online environments? How do students feel about the assessment and feedback they receive in online environments? It seems like either of these questions might provide lots of data collection and analysis opportunities.
Great start!
Jen--Your comments are helping me to think about the larger issues with my research idea. I do wonder if I would have to almost do two separate case studies (if that's the method I end up using)--one for face-to-face classes and one for an online course. I could focus just on online courses, but I'm really interested in how those classes compare to f2f courses and if more research about online courses would help scholars/teachers begin to see online courses as more "legitimate." Thanks for your ideas. I've got lots to consider!
ReplyDeleteDoing two cases studies - one f-2-f and one virtual section of each class - would be terrific, I think. You could spend a semester (or part of the semester) looking at each class. Might consider types of assignments, overall success (grades, passing rates, etc.) and student attitude. From there you could do a couple representative interviews (a faculty members and a couple students maybe?) from each class. Maybe a survey, too?
ReplyDeleteI can't wait to see what you come up with.