Sunday, October 11, 2009

Digital Environments and Virtual Research

Question 1-What special circumstances or considerations should be given to research done in an about online spaces (i.e. informed consent of "subjects", ethics, access, etc.)?

Answer 1-I think research done in online spaces should be treated just like research done in face-to-face or physical spaces whenever possible. If someone claims that digital research should be treated differently, that person is suggesting that virtual research should be valued differently (and most likely this would mean valued less than other more traditional forms of research). We've all heard of up-and-coming scholars fearing that tenure committees won't value their virtual research. Because this is a real fear (although, I think the appreciation of virtual research and writing is changing), virtual research should reflect practices relating to consent, ethics, and so on that traditional research follows.

I think it is important to get consent of "participants" even when they don't know they are participants. Yes, this could make research much, much more difficult. For instance, how could we get consent from someone in Second Life? Second Life participants could very easily ignore my request for consent to study their communities. But, as many people argue, the internet is a "public" space, and information is available to all people. So is consent needed in this case? I can see the argument that people can change certain settings to private, but not all people know how to do this. I don't think we can, as researchers, make any assumptions about whether or not people want their information to be public. Also, just because someone's information is "private," it does not mean that people can't get to it. There are many ways around privacy settings.

Question 2-What are some of the major benefits you see in virtual research? What are some of the disadvantages?

Answer 2-Virtual research is very relevant. It is beginning to explore a space where most of our interaction takes place today. By researching how people communicate or make meaning in these spaces, we are better able to understand how to help our students learn to become not only examiners of texts but also rhetorical producers of texts. Virtual research allows us to examine new writing practices, and as McKee and DeVoss explain, virtual research requires us to make or adapt new methodologies to study writing practices and how they change. This new environment helps researchers to continually evaluate methodologies and their strengths and weaknesses.

Some disadvantages to virtual research do exist. For instance, most virtual research probably does not include any f2f interaction. Despite my interest in virtual research, I do feel that f2f interaction provides information about participants that researchers can't get any other way. I've read a lot about virtual teams in technical communication articles. No matter what technologies people use to communicate virtually, people claim that they feel more "respect" for their teammates once they meet teammates in f2f locations. I wonder if by never meeting virtual participants researchers are more or less likely to represent those participants accurately (if it is ever possible to represent people accurately, no matter what the location is). Face-to-face interactions also allow researchers to study body language, which I'm sure has an effect on how researchers understand participants, whether researchers admit this or not in their written studies.

Question 3-In light of research like Thurlow and McKay's, how do you think our students are likely to value online scholarship and research practices?

I think students see online research as "easier" when they first set out to complete a research assignment or paper. However, they quickly learn that research done online (Google or databases) can be very difficult because of the amount of information. They also realize that getting the exact information they need is hard. For instance, students, at least in first-year writing courses, don't understand that they must search many, many key terms before they will find the information they need. They are very likely to search one term and then become frustrated when they don't find anything they see as relevant. I like that the Digital Breadcrumbs piece values many different kinds of research practices and seeks "to offer a broader perspective on what constitutes legitimate and effective scholarly research." This idea opens up many possibilities for students when doing research. Although students do initially go to Google, I think they enjoy using databases offered through the library because they find more relevant and useful information.

I do see some problems, though, with this move towards online research practices. I never noticed this problem until coming to NMSU. Many of my students, I suspect, do not have internet or even a computer at home, so online research is probably harder for them to learn how to do. Yes, students can use computers on campus, but many of them can't spend all day and night on campus. Most of the work I get done happens in my apartment, so thankfully I have a computer and internet connection to use at home. I think this example shows that there is still largely a economic divide between who can and cannot do successful online research. And that makes me think that the research we (scholars) do in online spaces is probably skewed by who has access to online technologies. This could be problematic for researchers who want to generalize their study results to a larger population.

4 comments:

  1. YESS!!! Rachel, I couldn't agree more with your last concern. I think we often forget about issues of access.

    Also, I have to admit that I enjoy making my students do library research. The internet, yes, is convenient, but...I REALLY like for my students to physically flip through pages to conduct at least some of their research. Don't get me wrong, I value online research but think that we shouldn't forget to introduce students to traditional research as well.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think the access issue is definitely prevalent, particularly in areas economically similar to Las Cruces.

    While I hate to sound cruel or insensitive or niave, I will here risk being all three-- most probably the last. I think we do have to understand our students contexts and situations. However, students also need to make a commitment to their courses when they enroll in the university. In these times, having or finding computer and internet access is a significant part of that commitment. Nobody pretends that education isn't about power or privilege; this is part of that dynamic.

    Don't get me wrong. I'm totally a push over as a teacher. I will work with my students with access issues. We can't, however, snail mail assignments or announcements to our students and expect that to be effective.

    Basically, I'm split on the issue. I believe access issues exist and are directly related to power hierarchies, but I also think access is an integral part of college success.

    There were a lot of other things in your post that I totally agreed with and got really excited about. I agree with some of what you're saying about private/public issues in online spaces and appreciate the ethical stance behind your position. I don't want to write forever on your post, so I'm going to stop here.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm going to organize this clumsily so as to keep track of my thoughts:

    1. I like that you immediately refer to the "exchange-value" of virtual research. We can look at a book like the SL ethnography and think that it looks great and cool, and we can be fascinated by it, but until we're the ones signing the checks, it won't matter a lick. I think *think* you're right about virtual scholarship becoming gradually more accepted, but when I think about the difficulties some college administrators have in accepting non- current traditional pedagogies, I wonder...

    2. I like the point you make about f2f interaction (a digression: is that "f2f" a way to rhetorically downplay the importance of physical interaction?) being an important component of online communitizing in teams. We're reading Derrida in Kathryn's Cultural Studies class, and I'm sorry, but I"m going to make a comparison. Thinking that the signifiers of the virtual world don't refer to (admittedly partial, constantly deferred) signifieds is a mistake. We are always in the real world--sometimes we're looking at computer screens.

    3. I (heart) technology access issues! And I totally agree with your concern that as classes move more and more toward electronic and digital research, those students who don't have access to computers or the skills to use them will be left out to dry. For some reason, you have me thinking of my grandmother who recently gave up on email. While she is not the typical English 111 student, I wonder if she feels that her subject position has been threatened by this move to digital spaces.

    I hope this makes sense...thanks for making me think...

    ReplyDelete
  4. Rachel-
    I love the point that you (and later Seth) is making about really valuing the virtual spaces and worlds. It's easy to dismiss these spaces and practices, but the lives lived in these spaces are real and are no less valuable than offline communication, relationships, or experiences.
    I think your suggestion that we do our best to maintain our traditional research ethics in these nontraditional spaces is good advice.
    Jen

    ReplyDelete